Both
Michelin and
Goodyear have been leading tyre manufacturing companies for many years now, developing top of the range tyre models with advanced features and performances.
Amongst the iconic tyres these two manufacturers have made over the years, some of their most impressive modern tyre advancements can be found in the Michelin Pilot Sport 4, and the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5.
Michelin Pilot Sport 4 Overview
The
Pilot Sport 4 was released by Michelin in 2016 and has since been a staple in the brand’s model line-up.
The tyre model is considered by many to be one of the most popular tyres in the industry today, boasting high performance levels in various weather conditions with great wet braking performances and excellent longevity.
The efficient steering response is supported by Michelin’s Dynamic Response Technology, making sure that the car’s steering is reactive and precise.
The
Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 was launched by Goodyear in 2019, becoming a popular tyre amongst customers shortly after.
Goodyear developed the Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 tyre to be a top-quality
premium tyre, using advanced technologies on tread designs to enhance its performance.
The tyre model boasts an
Impulse Control Compound Technology featured within the rubber compound – which helps to improve braking distances in different types of surface conditions.
The tread pattern also exhibits Power Cushion Technology for deliverance precise handling.
At Blackcircles.com, we understand how advanced and reliable these two tyre models are, but how do they stack up against each other?
From the information we have on both sets of tyres, we can break that question down accordingly.
Tyre Label Ratings
Tyre label ratings outline how tyre models rank in key factors of a tyre’s performance. Tyre label ratings will vary between different tyre sizes.
These performance indicators rank three different performance variables:
Fuel Efficiency – Ranked A to E
Wet Grip – Ranked A to E
Tyre Noise – Ranked A to C and Decibels
Pilot Sport 4 Label Ratings
The Pilot Sport 4’s fuel efficiency rating range from A – D,
with an average of C across the many sizes.
The Michelin tyre model also has an impressive wet grip rating of an A (on average), with some tyre model sizes featuring a minimum B wet grip ranking.
Depending on tyre size, the range of tyre noise rankings for the Pilot Sport 4 is 70B to 73B
Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 Label Ratings
The Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 has different fuel efficiency ratings, ranging from A – D, seeing an average rating of a B.
Wet grip for the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5, like the Pilot Sport 4, will have a rating of either A or B, with the average between sizes being an A.
The tyre noise rating for the Goodyear tyre is between 68A and 73B, depending on size of the tyre.
Pilot Sport 4 Awards
Michelin are no strangers to award winning tyre models, meaning there is no surprise that the highly regarded Pilot Sport 4 has gained accolades over the years.
At the 2022 DriverReviews Awards, the Pilot Sport 4 (and
Pilot Sport 4S) gained awards for ’Best Tyres for Hot Hatches‘.
Another award of many for the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 is ‘Overall Performance’ from ADAC’s comparative test in 2020, still years after the products first release in 2016.
Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 Awards
The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 has also received awards and accolades in recent years, thanks to the premium performance of the tyre.
In 2019, the Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 was the named as the best in the ‘Wet Braking Test’ at the Auto Bild AllRad
SUV tyre test.
To go oversees from the UK, 2019 also saw the Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 gain the ‘Best Car Tyre’ in Spain at the second Hevea Awards.
Customer Reviews
Powered by DriverReviews, the Blackcircles.com review system allows customers to rate 4 different aspects of their previously purchased tyre model out of 5 stars.
The 4 categories in which customer rate their tyres are:
Overall rating
Would the customer buy the tyres again
Does the car feel better to drive
Were the tyres value for money
Pilot Sport 4 Customer Reviews
customers have reviewed the Pilot Sport 4 as follows:
Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 Customer Reviews
customers have reviewed the Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 as follows:
Pilot Sport 4 Tyre Sizes
Like most tyre models, the Pilot Sport 4 tyres are available in various sizes.
These sizes for the model arrive from 195/45 R17 up to 295/40 R19 tyres. The most popular tyre size for the Pilot Sport 4 is 225/40 R18.
See the most popular tyre sizes available for the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 below:
The Pilot Sport 4’s price will vary depending on tyre size.
Prices of the Michelin tyre model range from £107.88 to £327.22*, which is fully fitted prices that include VAT, delivery, fitting, balancing and disposal charges.
Fully fitted prices for the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 range from £ to £.
Fully fitted prices for the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 range from £ to £.
FAQs:
Which tyre lasts longer?
Michelin Pilot Sport 4 generally has stronger owner-reported longevity, but actual wear depends on vehicle, driving style and road conditions. If long tread life is a priority, the Pilot Sport 4 often gives a marginal advantage.
Are these tyres suitable for winter?
No - both are summer tyres and are not recommended for snowy/icy winter conditions. If you drive in winter regularly, consider an all-season or dedicated winter tyre.
How do I pick the right size?
Confirm your tyre size from the sidewall or vehicle manual (e.g., 225/40 R18). Use our tyre size selector at on the homepage to compare prices, label ratings and availability.
PayPal Credit and PayPal Pay in 3 are trading names of PayPal UK Ltd, 5 Fleet Place, London, United Kingdom, EC4M 7RD. Terms and conditions apply. Credit subject to status and approval, 18+ UK residents only. PayPal Credit and PayPal Pay in 3 are a form of credit, so carefully consider whether the purchase is affordable and how you will make the repayments. PayPal Pay in 3 is not regulated by the FCA. See product terms for more details and FAQs. Learn more about PayPal Credit.Learn more about PayPal Pay in 3.
